By RICK MILLER
Olean Star
ALLEGANY — More than 100 people attended Monday night’s Right Thinkers meeting on the proposed Hemlock Hollow Wind Farm in Allegany, Olean and Portville.
The conservative group hosted a panel discussion on Hemlock Hollow, which has been “paused” by the developer, Liberty Renewables, at The Hall in Allegany. Right Thinkers co-founder Nate Smith served as moderator.
Liberty Renewables has proposed 19 wind turbines standing 650 feet tall from tip blade to the ground — 12 in the town of Allegany, five in Olean and two in Portville — c capable of generating 95 megawatts of electricity.
Panelists included: environmental attorney Gary Abraham, retired advertising executive Jeff Patch, mental health counselor Chris Anderson and Corey Wiktor, executive director of the Cattaraugus County Industrial Development Agency.
Also attending were members of the newly-formed Save Our Enchanted Mountain Ridges Alliance (SOEMRA).
The panelists discussed health issues associated with wind turbines, including how wind farms are sited, why the state is committed to wind energy, who pays — ratepayers or taxpayers and what residents and municipalities can do to push back and block renewable energy projects like Hemlock Hollow.
While Liberty Renewables “pause” on Hemlock Hollow is in effect, Patch, who is also a member of SOEMRA, had some suggestions on what can be done by individuals, groups and municipalities.

“Municipalities need strong solar and wind laws,” Patch said. “Some locally don’t even have them. So this pause is the perfect time to develop them, and for other cities and towns, perhaps to even strengthen them.”
Patch said SOERA has also asked the towns of Allegany and Portville and the City of Olean to consider consolidated legal status with the Town of Olean, which has hired an attorney with ORES (Office of Renewable Energy Siting) proceedings.
Drawing on his experience in advertising and public affairs, Patch said, “Residents need to engage in an integrated grass roots communications campaign. Grass roots was often code for we have no budget. We can make our voices heard.”
He said “Liberty Renewables and its Dutch parent company are listening. We need other stakeholders to listen — the public, city, town and county leadership.”
SOEMRA has started the public outreach with its press coverage and yard signs, Patch said. He said a direct mail campaign to property owners — some of whom may have already signed leases — is about to start — in hopes some may reconsider.
In addition, Patch urged those attending to ask others what they think about Hemlock Hollow. Most local people don’t know about it, he said.
Abraham, who authored the Town of Olean’s wind law, said the state has diminished municipalities’ ability to fight wind farms, but not eliminated it. “Towns have to have a good wind law,” he said. Olean has a good wind law, Allegany’s needs updating and Portville does not have a wind law.
Patch agreed, recommending the towns develop strong solar and wind laws.
Reasonable provisions to the law should include setbacks. The developer may have to request waivers to reasonable provisions the project cannot meet. Intervenors can challenge the waiver requests.
Abraham said that while municipalities can receive host fees and payments in lieu of taxes on wind farms, concerns remain regarding long-term health risks and long-term financial costs.

He said a safe setback of a residence from a wind turbine would be about a mile. Wind turbines that greatly increase background noise can be unhealthy to nearby residents. For example, people would notice an unhealthy increase in noise if background noise of 25 decibels increased to 45 decibels. Flicker from the shadow of wind turbine blades can also be unhealthy.
The panelists discussed the blasting that will be needed to excavate holes big enough for the concrete foundations of the wind turbines. The blasting into the mountain ridges will be in the same vicinity as the Chipmunk area’s oil production infrastructure and springs local residents use for drinking water. It will take 80 cement trucks to build the foundation for each turbine.
Liberty Renewables has touted the fact that Hemlock Hollow would be the first wind farm to be built in the same footprint as oil and gas wells — some that date back more than 100 years.
Anderson, an environmental scientist turned mental health counselor, suggested that pamphlets be distributed with facts about groundwater disruption and blasting to help spread awareness among area residents.
He said the mountains contain many rare plants including orchids and the waters feed native brook trout streams. Liberty Renewables announced the pause soon after it held a public meeting at the Marcus Park pavilion in Olean. Anderson said he didn’t think the company was reconsidering the project, merely delaying it. “We can’t let our guard down.”
Wiktor urged opponents to form coalitions like SOEMRA, maintain high visibility with signs and actively participate with local governments. He said the IDA has a policy of not providing tax incentives to wind projects that people and municipalities clearly do not want.
Wiktor also noted that Hemlock Hollow includes the same Chipmunk area that the former proposed EverPower wind project the Town of Allegany rejected in 2013.
Patch said the impact of the turbines spinning at up to 200 miles per hour will disturb neighbors and wildlife, including killing many bats and eagles. To construct the wind farm, habitat will be destroyed and trees clear cut for turbines and roads.
Anderson said residents drawn by the beauty of the mountains will face anxiety and depression from the impact on their mental, physical and social health. The turbines will affect their quality of life.
Abraham said the wind farms represent a “no risk” project for developers who scoop up state and federal tax credits that pay about half of the cost of construction. They can receive renewable energy tax credits over the 20- to 30-year lifespan of the wind farm.
Patch urged the audience to start asking people what they think about Hemlock Hollow. “A majority of the public has no idea what Hemlock Hollow is,” he explained.
Patch said opponents of the wind farm “need to use this time effectively.” He urged them to join SOEMRA on Facebook and attend meetings or scan the QR code on the signs SOEMRA is placing throughout the area.
Anderson said there is one bright spot in the state’s quest for green energy. Gov. Hochul, he said, is proposing small modular nuclear power plants to provide constant energy, unlike wind and solar.
Abraham said it should be up to local communities to determine whether these projects are worth the health risks.
Patch said municipalities need to update solar and wind laws. “Now is the time to strengthen them.”
Discover more from Olean Star
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.







